Fort Myers Beach Council Pushes Forward Pink Shell’s 40-Unit Hotel Project
In a key vote, the Fort Myers Beach Town Council voted 3-1 in favor of Pink Shell Beach Resort’s plans for a six-story building. The project, combining hotel rooms and condos, will move forward to a second hearing.
Council members will look over final paperwork before making their decision on February 3, 2025. Staff currently use the empty lot across from the main resort building for parking.
Bill Waichullis, who manages the resort, sees two main benefits: more jobs and returning tourists. Waichullis says, “We need some development on the island. You go down, there’s not much happening, and we need new development happening on this island.” He notes that Hurricane Ian destroyed many accommodations, making new rooms essential for visitors wanting to come back.
The vote proceeded without Mayor Dan Allers, who recused himself due to connections to the project. Local residents are split – some want more rooms restored, while others worry about increased traffic.
Former mayor Ray Murphy opposes any construction there. He believes the land should remain empty and is concerned about a trend: new buildings going up larger than those destroyed by Ian.
Local resident Lynn Shultz supports more hotels but has concerns about crowded streets and infrastructure. Some think the building’s height is excessive, though it’s near existing towers up to 11 stories tall.
Pink Shell has grown stronger over time. They invested $70 million in improvements in 1998, then built White Sand Villas six years later. Since Ian struck in 2022, they’ve worked to repair the damage.
The property’s history dates back to the 1920s when Estero Island saw a building boom. Major storms in ’21 and ’26 halted progress, but people returned, building homes and community spaces.
Today’s Pink Shell balances nature with business. They prioritize environmental stewardship and community relations in their daily operations.
The final decision comes in February. This vote could help accelerate the beach’s recovery from the hurricane.
